One Down, Three to Go

The first pair of socks in my Nancy Bush mini-masters sock study is a wrap.  Which means, mathematical reader, that I've got one down and three to go. 

Madder Ribbed Sock from Nancy Bush's Knitting Vintage Socks

These ribbed socks feature a Dutch Heel and a Star Toe.  Would I knit this heel again?  No.  I find the Dutch Heel to be very square -- and when worn it doesn't stay centered, tending to slip and slouch.  Although it was quite easy to knit, this style heel scores a 5 on a scale of 1 to 10.

The Dutch Heel is very square and tends to slip when worn. 
I do like the look of the "seam stitch" running down the middle.

How about the toe?  Would I knit the Star Toe again?  Yes.  I really like this toe.  It's a little longer and pointer than other style toes and I like how it fits.  The toe is shaped symmetrically around 4 points, which is very pretty.  The Star Toe scores an 8 on my 10 point scale.

You can just make out 2 of the 4 shaping lines of this Star Toe

Overall I like how these socks turned out -- loving the yarn, ribbing, and toe, while feeling mediocre about the heel.  It's fun experimenting with various heels and toes and I look forward to casting on my 2nd pair in this sock study -- the "Lichen Ribbed Socks".